Roy Keane on Elliot Anderson’s controversial red card after his foul on Lamine Yamal during England vs Spain:
I know most people will view this from a different perspective, but that’s not what I’m focused on.
My focus is on what happened before the red card.
Jarell Quansah has possession. He’s attempting to play the ball out, and the next thing I see is Lamine Yamal coming in aggressively on him. I’m not citing this as an excuse — Yamal genuinely fouled him.
The referee sees it and takes no action.
That’s significant.
England are already three goals up. They’re delivering an outstanding performance and controlling the match, and then a crucial decision goes against them right in front of the referee.
Spain win the ball from that moment. Yamal picks it up, and now Elliot Anderson is back defending.
And suddenly everyone wants to concentrate on Anderson.
‘Oh, he’s holding Yamal.’
Yes.
‘He’s the last defender.’
Yes.
‘He committed a foul.’
Yes.
I’m not going to stand here and claim Anderson did the right thing. He didn’t. When you’re the last defender, you have to grasp the consequences of grabbing a player like Yamal.
But let’s think rationally for a moment.
It’s the 65th minute.
England are leading 3-0.
If Yamal gets through and scores, it’s 3-1.
You still have a two-goal advantage.
Is conceding a goal frustrating? Of course.
But getting sent off and leaving your teammates a man down for the final twenty-five minutes is potentially much worse.
So no, Anderson shouldn’t have grabbed him. He made a poor decision.
But that’s not the main issue for me.
The main issue is what happened to Quansah.
Was that a foul?
Yes.
Did the referee see it?
Yes.
Was any action taken?
No.
Did VAR go back and properly examine the incident that started the whole sequence?
Apparently not.
Instead, all the attention shifts to the red card.
That’s where football becomes baffling.
We have all these rules. We have VAR. We have referees, assistants, technology, replays from ten different angles.
And yet sometimes it seems like the officials choose which part of the sequence they want to investigate.
If Yamal fouls Quansah, stop the play there.
England keep possession.
There’s no counterattack.
There’s no situation where Anderson is forced to defend Yamal running through.
And there’s no red card.
So yes, Anderson made a mistake.
But England were also denied an important decision before that mistake ever occurred.
And I’m tired of football pretending those two things can’t both be true at the same time.
You can criticise the player for the red card and still criticise the referee for missing the foul that created the situation.
That’s not making excuses.
That’s examining the whole incident.
Because if we only punish the final mistake and ignore what caused it, then what exactly is VAR there for?
The rules are supposed to make football clearer.
Sometimes the way they’re applied just makes the whole thing more confusing.