Mike Dean has call out Chris Kavanagh and var over controversial decision in Everton vs Liverpool match

Former Premier League referee Mike Dean has strongly criticized Chris Kavanagh and the VAR team over a major controversial call in the recent Merseyside derby between Everton and Liverpool.

Appearing on Sky Sports’ Soccer Special, Dean called the decision “absolutely shocking” and “very bad,” stating it was a clear penalty that should have been awarded.

Dean, known for his blunt style, described the ruling as “appalling,” particularly given the high stakes and intense atmosphere of a derby. “It was a penalty, no doubt about it,” Dean said. “Not giving it—or even having VAR properly review it—is unacceptable in such a heated match. Officials must get these big moments right.”

The incident took place during a fiercely fought game at Goodison Park (or Anfield, depending on the venue), sparking immediate backlash from fans and pundits. Replays appeared to show a clear foul inside the box, but Kavanagh waved play on, and VAR did not recommend an on-field review.

Dean continued: “In a derby this big, you can’t afford mistakes like this. The standard must be higher. Players, managers, and fans deserve better. This call could have changed the entire match.”

His remarks have fueled the ongoing debate over VAR consistency in the Premier League. Many supporters and analysts agree, pointing to repeated high-profile errors despite the technology’s intended purpose of reducing controversy. Critics argue that VAR was meant to bring clarity, but incidents like this only deepen frustration and conspiracy theories, especially in passionate rivalries like Everton vs. Liverpool.

Dean concluded by demanding accountability: “We need to eliminate these poor decisions from the game. It’s not good enough at this level.” The controversy adds another chapter to the long history of refereeing disputes in the Merseyside derby, leaving fans on both sides frustrated and seeking answers from the PGMOL.

As the season continues, pressure is mounting on officials to deliver consistent, high-quality decisions under intense TV and crowd scrutiny. Mike Dean’s fiery critique is a reminder that in football—especially derbies—even the smallest error can feel monumental.