Ryan Day should never have needed a national championship to validate his worth to Ohio State fans. For a coach steering a program that consistently competes for titles, it’s puzzling that some continue to question his future. Under Day’s leadership, the Buckeyes have made four College Football Playoff appearances in six years and competed in two national championship games. Yet, for certain critics, even that level of success falls short.
After a fourth consecutive loss to Michigan and missing out on a Big Ten title, some are speculating whether Day’s tenure with the Buckeyes might be nearing its end. However, when you examine his record, it’s clear he has more than proven his capabilities. His winning percentage surpasses that of Jim Tressel during a comparable timeframe, and his SP+ rating even eclipses Urban Meyer’s. Despite these impressive metrics, the narrative surrounding Day continues to revolve around the pressure to secure a national championship.
Day’s accomplishments shouldn’t be overlooked. He has guided Ohio State to consistent success, maintaining the program’s reputation as a powerhouse in college football. The Buckeyes have remained in the national conversation year after year under his watch, which is no small feat given the ever-growing competitiveness of the sport. Moreover, his ability to recruit top talent and adapt strategically has ensured Ohio State’s sustained prominence on the national stage.
Criticism often stems from the intense expectations that come with leading a program of Ohio State’s caliber. For some fans, anything less than a national title feels like a failure. However, this perspective overlooks the challenges of navigating a season filled with high-stakes games, injuries, and the constant pressure to deliver results. The fact that Day has kept Ohio State in the hunt for championships is a testament to his leadership and vision.
The calls for his job after another loss to Michigan are premature and fail to recognize the broader picture. Rivalries, especially one as storied as Ohio State-Michigan, are cyclical, and no coach is immune to setbacks. Day’s overall body of work—marked by consistent excellence and an unwavering commitment to the program—demonstrates that he is the right person for the job.
Ohio State fans should take a step back and appreciate what Day has accomplished. His track record, when compared to past Buckeye greats, speaks for itself. While a national title would undoubtedly cement his legacy, it shouldn’t be the sole measure of his success. Day has already shown he can sustain Ohio State’s status as one of the premier programs in college football, and that alone deserves recognition. Regardless of Monday’s outcome, Ryan Day has earned the trust and support of Buckeye Nation.
